Verified dupe · Toner
The History of Whoo Cheongidan Hwahyun Refining Pad vs SKIN1004 Madagascar Centella Toning Toner
See all 82 The history of Whoo dupes →As of Jun 27 · Prices reflect public listings on stores such as Coupang and may vary by store or promotion.
Why this dupe
The proof is in the ingredients, not the price
Gluconolactone, Hyaluronic Acid and other key ingredients appear in both full ingredient lists.
In the full lists, 6 ingredients overlap.
Who it's for
Good for smoothing texture while keeping skin calm. Both carry an exfoliating PHA ingredient and hyaluronic acid for hydration, so they look after a few concerns at once.
What works and what to weigh
- Calming and exfoliation close to the luxury pick
- The dupe skips fragrance
- About 32% cheaper
- –The luxury pick adds a calming fermented ingredient and a tone ingredient, so it works with more actives.
Dupe match score
A blended score across key ingredients, benefit match, category and price. It reflects how recommendable the alternative is, not how identical the two products are.
Efficacy
The ingredients aren't identical, but both products aim at similar benefits. Each row shows which side covers it.
4 contributing ingredients
3 contributing ingredients
2 contributing ingredients
4 contributing ingredients
2 contributing ingredients
Key shared ingredients · 2 (1 uncommon)
The key ingredients both products share — the basis for the match.
A milder PHA used to refine surface texture.
A signature humectant that pulls in and holds water, leaving skin hydrated and smooth.
Neither list has a preservative-type marker with a known concentration cap. So we cannot tell how much of each shared ingredient these two products actually contain, and we would rather say that than guess.
Full ingredient comparison
Both full ingredient lists compared. More shared ingredients means a closer match.
Ingredients are listed by amount. Below 1%, brands may list them in any order, so ranking there means little.
Compared by full ingredient list. It does not mean concentration or texture are identical, and prices are as of the listed time.
Check before you buy
One last look before you buy: watch-outs, what each skips, and usage tips.
Watch-outs
The History of Whoo
SKIN1004
Fragrance, parabens, etc. that some prefer to avoid. Products within labeled limits are generally fine.
Not included
Whether each product contains ingredients some prefer to avoid. A preference, not a safety verdict.
Before you reach for this dupe
- Pair it with sunscreen during the day.
How skin responds to ingredients varies from person to person. If your skin is sensitive or you have a specific condition, check with a doctor first.
₩15,660₩23,110
SKIN1004 Madagascar Centella Toning Toner
As a Coupang Partners affiliate, we earn a commission on qualifying purchases.
Other verified dupes
How we pick a dupe
We compare the full ingredient lists and only pair products that share core actives. Prices are checked against market listings, and ingredients with Korea MFDS usage standards are flagged on the page.
Disclaimer
This comparison is based on full-ingredient (INCI) data published under cosmetics law.
Shared ingredients mean the full-ingredient lists overlap, not that blend concentrations match; how a product feels and performs can differ by formulation and ingredient grade.
Prices are market-verified against stores such as Coupang and may differ from official store prices; discounts and temporary changes may not be reflected, so check the seller before buying.
For sensitive skin, eczema, pregnancy or other special cases, please do not decide on this analysis alone and consult a dermatologist.
Product images are displayed from Naver Shopping search results, and the rights to each image belong to the respective seller or brand.
This is an information service to support reasonable choices, and the final purchase decision is yours.